Experimental Measurements of Momentum Transfer in Hypervelocity

46th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference (2015)
2894.pdf
EXPERIMENTAL MEASUREMENTS OF MOMENTUM TRANSFER IN HYPVELOCITY COLLISIONS.
K. R. Housen and K. A. Holsapple, 1The Boeing Co., P.O. Box 3707, Seattle WA 98124, [email protected], 2Univ. Washington, 352400, Seattle WA, 98195, [email protected]
Introduction: Hypervelocity collisions affect the
rotational states of asteroids and have been suggested
as a method for altering the orbits of potentially hazardous bodies. Both of these processes depend significantly not only on the projectile momentum, but also
on the impulse contained in the excavated surface material that permanently escapes the asteroid. Given that
the volume of a hypervelocity impact crater can be
orders of magnitude larger than the impactor volume,
and that much of the ejecta escape the weak gravity
field of a small asteroid, the impulse contribution from
the ejecta can be significantly larger than the direct
contribution from the impactor.
The efficiency of this process is characterized by a
parameter, β, defined as the total momentum change of
the asteroid divided by the momentum of the
impacting projectile. In the limiting case of a perfectly
inelastic collision (no ejecta), β=1.
When a
considerable mass of ejecta escapes, β can be
significantly greater than 1.
We use experiments, scaling analysis and shock
wave codes (hydrocodes) to study the momentum
transfer for a deflection mission. The purpose of this
abstract is to summarize our recent experiments.
Experiments: The impact experiments are
performed in the Boeing Shock Physics Lab, as well as
at the NASA Ames Vertical Gun Range. As described
in previous reports (1), the target container is suspended in an evacuated impact chamber by four steel
springs whose attachment points are equally spaced
around the perimeter of the bowl-shaped container.
The impacts occur vertically, normal to the target
surface. The projectiles are either polyethylene cylinders or aluminum or nylon spheres. The impact velocity ranges from 0.5 to 5.7 km/s.
A Keyence laser displacement gage aimed at the
bottom of the target container measures the vertical
oscillations of the target caused by the impact. The
laser records determine the frequency ω and amplitude
H of the oscillations. The impulse delivered to the
target is HωM/2, where M is the mass of the target.
That impulse, divided by the initial projectile momentum, gives the value of β for the experiment.
Asteroids and comets exhibit a rich diversity of
shapes, bulk densities, reflection spectra and surface
features. This undoubtedly reflects a corresponding
diversity in the mechancial properties of the surface
materials, which affect the amount and speed of
material ejected during a collision. Our approach is to
measure β for a wide variety of target material types
and configurations to reveal the range of β that could
be expected during hypervelocity collision events.
The target materials include dry sand, various types
of nonporous rock (monolithic blocks of Columbia
basalt and High Sierra granite, and “river rock”, obtained from a landscape supplier), coherent pumice
with density=0.87 gm/cm3 and ~70% porosity, granular
pumice with a bulk density of 84%, various sizes of
basalt gravel, and simulants of regolith-covered asteroids consisting of a layer of sand over competent rock.
Results: The point-source theory of hypervelocity
impact indicates that β should generally increase with
impact speed (2).
In particular, β-1, i.e. the
contribution from the ejecta, should increase as a
power of speed. The figure below shows our current
set of experimental results as a log-log plot of β-1 vs
impact speed U, in which case the power-law
dependence becomes a straight line.
We find that competent, nonporous rock exhibits
the highest value of β, due to the high ejecta velocities
observed for these materials. Extrapolating the
observed power-law dependence, β could be as large
as 10 at speeds of 15 to 20 km/s. At the other extreme,
highly porous materials, such as pumice, tend to show
much lower values of β, often close to the inelastic
limit of β =1. This is due to the rapid decay of the
shock in porous materials, and correspondingly low
ejection velocities (3). Granular materials, such as
sand or gravel, lie between these two cases. Dry sand
targets (green data points) have small β at the low
impact speeds, but could reach 4 to 5 at speeds of 15 to
20 km/s.
Impacts into gravel targets, meant as rough analogs
of blocky rubble-pile asteroids, fall between those of
sand and competent rock. The large gray squares in
the figure are for coarse gravel targets where the gravel
particles (~45 mm dia) where about 7x larger than the
aluminum projectile. The smaller gray squares correspond to two finer sizes of gravel, the finest having
particle sizes comparable to the projectile. The results
for fine gravel approach those for sand, as expected.
Increasing the constituent particle size generally produces larger values of β, and would presumably approach the competent rock line for sufficiently large
particles.
46th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference (2015)
We have performed four experiments with targets
consisting of a layer of dry sand on top of a block of
competent basalt (small blue squares). The line connecting the two points in the figure corresponds to a
layer that is four projectile diameters deep. When the
regolith depth is doubled, β increases noticeably (the
highest small blue square). A further increase in the
layer depth causes a reduction in β. This is expected
because for sufficiently deep layers, the projectile and
2894.pdf
the cratering flow is not affected by the deeply buried
rock layer. Further results and implications of these
experiments will be presented.
References: [1] Housen K.R. and Holsapple K.A.
(2011) 42nd Lunar Planet. Sci. Conf., 2363. [2] (1)
Holsapple, K. and Housen, K. (2012) Icarus, 221, 875887. [3] Housen and Holsapple (2011), Icarus 211,
856-875.
Figure 1. Experimental measurements of the momentum enhancement factor, β.