Temperature Effects on the Reflectance Spectra of Olivine and

46th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference (2015)
2858.pdf
TEMPERATURE EFFECTS ON THE REFLECTANCE SPECTRA OF OLIVINE AND PLAGIOCLASE.
L. M. Corley1 and J. J. Gillis-Davis1, 1Hawai‘i Institute of Geophysics and Planetology, University of Hawaiʻi at
Mānoa, 1680 East-West Road, Honolulu, HI 96822, USA ([email protected]).
Introduction: The spectral properties of minerals
may vary with temperature, likely caused by changes
in the interatomic spacing and the crystal field. A series of laboratory experiments by Roush and Singer
showed that the width, area, and placement of absorption bands in mafic silicates may change in relation to
temperature [1, 2, 3]. Hinrichs and Lucey [4] quantified the dependence of spectral properties on temperature for mafic minerals, lunar soils, and meteorites. For
mafic minerals, they showed that the absorption bands
broaden and the 2-µm absorption band of orthopyroxene shifts to longer wavelengths with increasing temperature. In addition, the reflectance of pyroxene at
1,050 nm increases with decreasing temperature.
The importance for considering surface temperature in remotely sensed data is underscored by reflectance measurements made by the Lunar Orbiter Laser
Altimeter (LOLA) [5, 6] and the Mercury Laser Altimeter (MLA) [7]. LOLA measured a spike in brightness
at 1,064 nm in permanently shadowed regions (PSRs).
Suggested causes were water ice, mass wasting, or
reduced space weathering [5]. In addition, there is a
clear antircorrelation trend between temperature and
reflectance in LOLA data [8]. Lucey et al. [8] hypothesized that the trend is due to an influence of temperature on space weathering.
Previous laboratory experiments [4] have shown
that the overall effect of temperature on the spectral
properties of lunar soils is minute, though measurable.
The maximum change in relative reflectance with temperature is on the order of 1% or less per 100 K, compared to about 5–10% for the ordinary chondrites and
HEDs and up to 35% for pure minerals [4]. This minute reflectance change is not enough to explain the
brightness increase observed in the LOLA data. It was
proposed that space weathering masked the temperature effect on spectral properties [4]. Hence we aim to
test this hypothesis by measuring reflectance dependent changes of plagioclase as a function of temperature
and laser space weathering using a thermally controlled chamber. Our experimental setup is guided by
hypothesis that the lower surface temperatures of the
polar regions and the extremely low temperatures in
PSRs (as low as 50 K) affect the melting and development of SMFe, particularly in the presence of potential
volatiles. Such effects could influence the spectral reflectance of the materials within PSRs. Hence a decrease in the production of SMFe would reduce the
ability of space weathering to mask the temperature
effect on spectral properties. We began this investigation by first examining the effect of temperature on
olivine and plagioclase.
Methods: We collected spectra of powdered San
Carlos olivine (<150 µm) and Stillwater plagioclase
(<75 µm) at varying temperatures. Samples were
placed in the same thermal vacuum chamber used by
[4], which controls the radiation environment on the
sample using liquid nitrogen for cooling (Fig. 1). A
vacuum pressure of 1-2×10-6 torr was achieved using
Pfeiffer Hi-cube oil-free turbo and roughing pump
combination.
Figure 1: Experimental setup, with the light and optics
shown in the position for measuring reflectance of a Spectralon standard.
Olivine was used in an attempt to reproduce the results of [4]. Plagioclase spectra were measured in order
to determine if plagioclase exhibits similar spectral
dependence on temperature as mafic minerals. Hinrichs and Lucey [4] did not measure the thermoreflectance spectrum of plagioclase. Work by Roush
[1] suggests that the spectrum of plagioclase is relatively inactive with respect to temperature. However,
in his experimental setup the radiative environment
was not controlled nor documented sufficiently to
model the influence of radiation. Furthermore, the true
thermodynamic temperature of the sample’s optical
surface is uncertain.
The temperature-controlled chamber was shown by
[4] to effectively act as a blackbody cavity. A Lake
Shore Cryotonics Inc. Model 321 Autotuning Temperature Controller recorded the temperatures measured
with silicon diode temperature sensors mounted inside
the chamber. Spectra were collected at temperatures
varied between ambient temperature and 90 K. Hin-
46th Lunar and Planetary Science Conference (2015)
richs and Lucey estimated that their measurements
were limited to a minimum temperature of 150 K from
radiative heating of the sample by the light source.
Reflectance measurements were taken with Analytical Spectral Devices Inc. (ASD) FieldSpec® FR Spectrometer, which measures reflectance from the UVVIS
to NIR (0.35-2.5 µm) with a full-width-half-max spectral resolution of 3 nm for 1000 nm and 10 nm for
1000-2500 nm. The windows in the chamber are situated such that the incidence and emissions angles are
10.5° and the phase angle is 21.0°. Reflectance was
measured relative to Spectralon standards at ambient
temperature. For olivine, we used the 20% and 40%
reflectance standards to bracket the average reflectance. The 40% and 60% reflectance standards were
used to bracket the average reflectance of plagioclase.
Results: Measurements of olivine spectra show a
broadening of the 1-µm absorption band with increasing temperature consistent with the experimental results of [1,2,3,4] (Fig. 2). Reflectance measurements of
plagioclase exhibit increased brightness with decreasing temperature (Fig. 3).
0.55
Absolute Reflectance
0.5
0.45
0.4
0.35
293 K
250 K
100 K
90 K
0.3
0.25
0.2
500
1000
1500
2000
Wavelength (nm)
Figure 2: Absolute reflectance spectra of San Carlos olivine
at ambient temperature (red), 250 K (black), 100 K (green),
and 90 K (blue).
Absolute Reflectance
0.65
0.6
0.55
230 K
200 K
0.5
170 K
125 K
0.45
100 K
90 K
0.4
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
Wavelength (nm)
1600
1800
2000
Figure 3: Absolute reflectance spectra of Stillwater plagioclase at 230 K (red), 200 K (orange), 170 K (black), 125 K
(green), 100 K (blue), and 90 K (purple).
2858.pdf
Discussion: Reflectance measurements of plagioclase in a temperature-controlled vacuum chamber
show an inverse correlation with temperature. Increased brightness was observed at temperatures comparable to average temperatures [6] of PSRs on the
Moon and Mercury. However, in lunar soils this temperature effect may be masked by the darkening effect
of space weathering [4]. Nevertheless, surface temperature must be considered for mineralogical interpretation of remotely obtained spectral reflectance data such
as LOLA and MLA.
Future Work: The goal of future experiments is to
understand the factors and their relative proportions
that contribute to increased reflectance at 1,064 nm as
measured by LOLA and MLA. We will first expand
our experiments to pure pyroxene and a mixture of
plagioclase, pyroxene, and olivine as an immature
highlands regolith analog. We will also add 3 wt.%
iron metal to plagioclase in order to simulate meteoritic iron [9].
Another set of experiments will aim to determine
the effects of space weathering at low temperatures.
We will perform laser induced space weathering experiments inside the thermal vacuum chamber at ~80 K.
Analyses will include reflectance measurements,
measurements of the volatiles released from the samples, and examination of any submicroscopic iron and
glassy patinas produced using transmission electron
microscopy. The space weathering experiments will
help test the hypothesis of [8] that a temperatureinduced reduction in the effectiveness of space weathering contributes to the increased reflectivity of PSRs.
References: [1] Roush T. L. (1984) , Effects of
temperature on remotely sensed mafic mineral absorption features, Master’s Thesis, University of Hawaii.
[2] Singer R. B. and Roush T. L. (1985) JGR, 90, B14,
12434-12444. [3] Roush T. L. and R. B. Singer (1986)
JGR. 91, B10, 10301-10308. [4] Hinrichs J. L. and
Lucey P. G. (2002) Icarus, 155, 169-180. [5] Zuber M.
T. et al. (2012) Nature, 486(7403), 378-381. [6] Paige
D. A. et al. (2013) AGU, Abstract P11A-03. [7] Neuman et al. (2013) Science, 339, 296-300. [8] Lucey P.
G. et al. (2014) JGR, 119, 1665-1679. [9] McKay D. S.
et al. (1991) in The Lunar Sourcebook, 285-356, Cambridge Univ. Press, New York.